Yoga Body

The two main studies in this area to date, by Elizabeth De Michelis and Joseph Alter, have focused on both these moments in the history of transnational yoga, but they have not offered a good explanation of why āsana was initially excluded and the ways in which it was eventually reclaimed.[YB 3] Next it explores in detail the impact of the international physical culture movement on India in the early 20th century, at a time of rising Indian nationalism, in reaction to British colonialism.[3] The historian Jared Farmer, in Reviews in American History, writes that the book does a great service in enabling study of "this creolized tradition",[4] he neither provides a single clear narrative, nor states which of the many causal factors he identifies are the most important."[4] Farmer suggests that Singleton may, by looking towards factors in British India, have overlooked some American contexts, and states that "Yoga Body deserves controversy, which I mean as a sincere compliment."[5] The yoga teacher Jill Miller, reviewing the book on Gaiam, observes that Singleton showed how many modern asanas were "derived during an environment of Indian neo-nationalism and infused with doses of European gymnastics, bodybuilding and the Christian agendas of the YMCA.""[8][YB 10] Admitting himself no expert on modern yoga, he identifies a series of medieval sources that describe non-seated asanas, from mayurasana (the peacock) in the 10th century Vimānārcanākalpa onwards.[10] Remski observed that there were ad hominem attacks on Singleton: he was labelled "a debunker, a cultural appropriator, a 'junior scholar from England', and a pro-colonial revisionist intent on delegitimizing the Indian roots of postural practice."[1] Remski notes that most of these emerged and vanished on social media, their ephemerality indicating their "intellectual poverty", but their presence demonstrating Yoga Body's reach to a non-academic audience, "and its sting.He suggested instead that it made more sense[1][2] to speak of adaptation, reframing, reinterpretation (and so on) rather than invention, insofar as these terms foreground the ongoing processes of experimentation and bricolage that characterise the recent history of globalised yoga, and keeps us away from debates about the genealogies and ultimate origins of particular postures.
Westerners viewed yoga with suspicion, grouping it with fakirs (pictured in 1907) and charlatanry . [ YB 3 ]
In Yoga Body , Singleton sets modern yoga in context with images such as this pose close to Samakonasana in Thomas Dwight 's "The Anatomy of a Contortionist", Scribner's Magazine , April 1889. [ YB 3 ]
Singleton argued that Astānga yoga may get its name not from Patañjali 's eight-fold yoga but from the aṣṭāṅga dandavat pranām pose. [ YB 10 ]
UstrasanaMark Singletonmodern yogaOxford University Pressyoga as exercisehatha yogaasanasasceticVivekanandavinyasasgymnasticsphysical cultureIndian nationalismsaffronisingmarketingāsanaElizabeth De MichelisJoseph AlterfakirscharlatanryyoginscolonialismHarmonial GymnasticsKrishnamacharyaMysorecontortionistsbodybuildersB. K. S. IyengarSamakonasanaThomas DwightScribner's MagazineJournal of Hindu-Christian StudiesJared FarmerReviews in American HistorycreolizedMatthew Remskisurya namaskārabodybuildingmartial artsAstānga yogaPatañjaliaṣṭāṅga dandavat pranāmJames Mallinsonsūrya namaskāreureka momentAṣṭāṅga yogamayurasanaVimānārcanākalpaRoots of YogaVrikshasanamindful yogaFrank Jude Bocciosyncretismad hominemYoga KoruntaB.K.S. IyengarLight on YogaprefaceAndrea JainGudrun BühnemannparamparahagiographicRemski, MatthewFarmer, JaredMallinson, JamesSingleton, MarkList of asanasStanding asanasDownward dogLotus positionMeditation seatsSun SalutationTree poseWarriorDrishtiNamastePranayamaVinyāsaHasta VinyasasTeacher trainingBritish Wheel of YogaEuropean Union of YogaAndré Van LysebethYoga AllianceTherapyYoga using propsAccessible yogaTrauma-sensitive yogaRestorative YogaYoga nidraInternational Association of Yoga Therapists • Richard MillerJanice GatesCompetitive yogaInternational Day of YogaAsana JournalYoga JournalYoga brickYoga matAngela FarmerHugger MuggerYoga pantsLululemonEarly modern yogaRaja YogaPierre BernardHarmonial gymnastics/yogaMarguerite AgnielMary Bagot StackGenevieve StebbinsB. C. GhoshK. V. IyerSeetharaman SundaramParamahansa YoganandaAutobiography of a YogiHot yogaScience of yogaSexual abuse by yoga gurusYoga and cultural appropriationIn advertisingFor childrenFor womenGeeta IyengarYoga tourismHybridsNaked yogaAnne CushmanJon Kabat-ZinnCyndi LeePhillip MoffittAcroyogaPaddleboard YogaAerial yogaBeer yogaAmericaYoga for HealthLilias, Yoga and YouBritainLyn MarshallFranceGermanyRussiaSwedenRachel BrathenSelvarajan YesudianYoga Tradition of the Mysore PalaceYoga in Modern IndiaA History of Modern YogaPositioning YogaThe Subtle BodySelling YogaThe Path of Modern YogaThe Story of YogaEnlighten Up!Breath of the GodsSchoolsThe Yoga InstituteShri YogendraHansa YogendraKaivalyadhamaSwami KuvalayanandaViniyogaTirumalai KrishnamacharyaYoga MakarandaT. K. V. DesikacharA. G. MohanIndra DeviSrivatsa RamaswamiVanda ScaravelliAshtanga Vinyasa YogaK. Pattabhi JoisMysore styleTim MillerKino MacGregorLarry SchultzSivananda YogaVishnudevananda SaraswatiComplete Illustrated Book of YogaBihar School of YogaSatyananda SaraswatiAnanda YogaKriyanandaIntegral YogaSatchidananda SaraswatiKripalu YogaAmrit DesaiStephen CopeHimalayan InstituteSwami RamaBikram YogaBikram ChoudhuryIyengar YogaYoga the Iyengar WayDharma MittraYin YogaPaulie ZinkPaul GrilleySarah PowersForrest YogaJivamukti YogaSharon GannonPower YogaBeryl Bender BirchBryan KestAnusara YogaJohn FriendCore Strength Vinyasa Yoga (Sadie Nardini)Post-lineage yogaList of yoga schoolsClassical yogaTheos BernardJason BirchJohannes BronkhorstEdwin BryantGudrun Bühnemann (Eighty-Four Asanas in Yoga)Mikel BurleyChristopher Key ChappleGeorg FeuersteinGavin FloodShaman HatleyGerald James LarsonMax MüllerGeoffrey SamuelAlexis SandersonSrisa Chandra VasuDavid Gordon WhiteBjarne Wernicke-OlesenErnest WoodSir John WoodroffeHeinrich ZimmerJoseph Alter (Yoga in Modern India)Elliott Goldberg (The Path of Modern Yoga)Andrea Jain (Selling Yoga)Elizabeth De Michelis (A History of Modern Yoga)Suzanne NewcombeGurus of Modern YogaNorman Sjoman (Yoga Tradition of the Mysore Palace)Theo Wildcroft (Post-lineage Yoga)